Recently, the collaborative toys released by KFC in partnership with the popular anime "Spy x Family" have sparked widespread discussion due to quality control issues. Multiple consumers have reported on social media that the Anya dolls they received have obvious stains, uneven painting, and even parts installed backwards, with some stains proving difficult to remove. This collaborative meal set went on sale starting September 6 and includes four random toys, but many fans have encountered the dual troubles of store stock shortages or poor product quality. Although some consumers successfully exchanged defective items, the incident still highlights the shortcomings in production and quality control for IP collaboration merchandise, which deserves attention from both brands and fans. [more…]

Luckin Coffee's collaboration with Line Friends' dog character officially returned this Monday, bringing back last year's beloved Little White Pear Latte, and fans eagerly placed orders to snap up the co-branded merchandise. However, many consumers discovered upon receiving the actual products that the limited-edition metal badges had issues such as scratches, bubbles, black spots, and even missing logos, while the blind-bag stickers were also complained about being insufficient in quantity. Faced with co-branded merchandise that they had waited a year for yet varied in quality, merch enthusiasts expressed their disappointment one after another, calling on Luckin to strengthen quality control. [more…]

The co-branding campaign between Chagee and "Ne Zha 2" had not yet been officially announced, but a large number of leaked merchandise images had already surfaced on social media, sparking heated discussion among fans. However, as more images were exposed, merchandise enthusiasts who had been full of anticipation discovered that the square badges in this design bore a striking resemblance to competitor Cotti's fridge magnets, and the quality also fell short of expectations, with disappointment written all over their faces. Facing the growing public discourse, Chagee's official account appeared in the comments section to debunk rumors and try to soothe fans' emotions. Meanwhile, Cotti, which was the first to launch its co-branded campaign, won praise for its sincerity and after-sales service, invisibly putting comparative pressure on Chagee. How will this co-branding controversy unfold? And what gaps exist between fans' expectations and the brand's preparations? [more…]

On the eve of Valentine's Day, Starbucks as usual launched its Rose 20 series drinks and a limited-edition bouquet-holding bear charm. However, reactions this season have been sharply polarized: on the drinks side, the new items use an extract from double-petaled roses, and the sugar-free formula had some consumers praising the natural floral aroma, while others said the scent was too intense and hard to accept; on the merchandise side, the bouquet-holding bear charm drew widespread complaints over quality-control issues, with flaws such as crooked eyes and mouth, a single eye, and multiple ears appearing frequently, leaving many fans who ordered it for its cute look deeply disappointed. What has upset longtime customers even more is that this is already Starbucks' second plush merchandise flop in a short period; the rabbit plush that previously came with a ceramic cup was also widely mocked for its uneven appearance. Will a string of quality problems affect the brand's reputation in the merchandise market? This article will take you through the whole story. [more…]

Nayuki's collaboration with the hit game "Reverse: 1999" was supposed to be a fan celebration, but it ran into embarrassment due to quality control issues with the merchandise. The official limited-edition luggage tags were reported by consumers to have ghosting in the printed designs, making the game characters look like their "souls had left their bodies," which was dizzying to look at. At the same time, the collaboration-themed cups caused the peelable small cards to stick together and become damaged due to condensation, greatly reducing their collectible value. The stores' response to requests for exchanges also failed to quell dissatisfaction. Why did this cross-industry collaboration, which was met with high expectations, repeatedly stumble over the details? And how should consumers' experience be safeguarded? [more…]

Manner recently launched a two-cup set that comes with a matte ceramic mug, but it has sparked widespread discussion due to issues such as water seeping from the bottom and the body cracking after hot water is poured in. Many consumers have reported on social media that this mug, which is claimed to be microwave- and dishwasher-safe, actually cracked suddenly during use, which is worrying. Store employees were even asked to remind customers not to fill it with overly hot liquids, a move that some users mocked with, "A ceramic mug that can't hold hot coffee—doesn't Manner find itself hilarious?" At the same time, some stores still have plenty of stock, in contrast to the previous scenes of being snapped up completely. Is it poor aesthetics, declining quality control, or safety concerns that have put off mug enthusiasts? This article takes you through the details. [more…]

Chagee recently launched the second wave of its "Ne Zha 2" co-branded limited-edition packaging across stores nationwide. The popular character Ao Guang is printed on paper bags and takeaway cups, sold in a bundle with "Seeking Fragrance Camellia." Buying one cup earns you a matching paper bag. As soon as the news broke, fans rushed to buy them, but after receiving the actual products, they were greatly disappointed: the pattern on the cup body has severe ghosting, so much so that people joked you'd need 3D glasses to see it clearly. The color difference between the themed cup, paper bag, and poster is obvious, and the details are blurred into a mosaic. Many consumers pointed out that the first batch of packaging had already suffered from problems like blurry printing and fading. They had expected the brand to improve its craftsmanship, but unexpectedly the second batch still flopped. In addition, some stores did not use the themed cups as advertised, which harmed the rights of delivery customers. As coffee enthusiasts, Front Street Coffee has also noticed this co-branded merchandise quality control controversy. This article will sort out the whole story and consumer feedback. [more…]

As people return to work after the holiday, coffee chains are rolling out merchandise to grab office workers' attention. Manner is releasing its popular ceramic cup in new colors as a limited edition, while Mstand has taken a different approach with a lunchbox jokingly dubbed the "cattle and horse trough," bundled with a new coffee-flavored latte as a limited two-cup set. However, once the actual product arrived, consumers found the lunchbox riddled with scratches, rough edges on the clasps, too small a capacity, and no indication on the material that it was microwave-safe, sparking widespread complaints. From looks to practicality, this piece of merchandise seems to have failed to meet the expectations of people who bring their own lunch. [more…]

Recently, Mstand opened a pop-up store called Mstand Market on the first floor of Teemall in Guangzhou, mainly selling merchandise. The store displays various cups, bags, and other merchandise, while coffee has become a supporting role in the package deals. This "buy merchandise, get coffee free" model has sparked heated discussions among consumers, with longtime customers saying it puts the cart before the horse. Mstand, once recognized for its coffee quality, has now become a topic of discussion because of its merchandise, and is even jokingly called "a coffee shop that survives by selling merchandise." The inconsistent quality of the merchandise and controversial pricing strategy make the brand's positioning shift lamentable. [more…]

Recently, a plastic washbasin offered by Mixue Bingcheng as a周边 (merchandise) for spending 15 yuan or more has sparked widespread discussion online. This plastic washbasin, printed with the brand's mascot Snow King, breaks the conventional impression that tea beverage brand merchandise must be exquisite and attractive, with its plain and simple appearance and highly down-to-earth positioning. Netizens verbally complained that it was "ridiculous," yet couldn't help placing orders. It is worth noting that this merchandise is not available in stores nationwide, but is concentrated in certain areas of Jiangsu and Zhejiang, which has made many fans envious. As a tea beverage brand known for low prices, affordability, and being down-to-earth, Mixue Bingcheng's move, though surprising, is actually quite reasonable upon reflection. This article will start from this phenomenon and explore the current state and changes of limited-edition merchandise from tea beverage brands. [more…]

Nayuki's official shop recently sold last year's co-branded limited-edition merchandise for 5.9 yuan with free shipping, including Powerpuff Girls fridge magnets, sparking strong dissatisfaction among consumers who had originally bought designated set meals to obtain the merchandise. Some store employees even revealed that some expired merchandise could be obtained for free without any purchase, simply by checking in and writing a positive review. On one side, fans who spent money on set meals feel let down; on the other, the brand is turning inventory into free gifts or selling it at low prices to avoid waste. Regarding how limited-edition merchandise is handled after a campaign ends, consumer opinions are clearly divided—some support clearing out stock, while others worry that bargain hunters exploiting loopholes could affect future collaborations. [more…]

Molly Tea has teamed up with Hello Kitty to launch limited-edition drinks and merchandise, drawing a flood of fans who raced to snap them up the moment sales opened. Yet once the promotion began, consumers in many cities reported that their payments went through but they never received the merchandise, and some stores even canceled orders without any notice. Customers who showed up to collect their orders were told the merchandise was first come, first served and would be given out only while supplies lasted, leaving some people to make the trip for nothing. As frustration mounted, disputes between customers and staff broke out at some stores, prompting calls to the police; officers advised those affected to defend their rights through channels such as 12315. The collaboration drew widespread complaints because of problems with merchandise inventory and order management. [more…]

Luckin Coffee's recent collaboration with the claymation character Pingu has sparked considerable discussion. In the early stage of the campaign, consumers had to buy designated set meals or two cups of the new drink to get the merchandise, and many fans placed orders at full price or even stockpiled coffee coupons for this. However, not long after the campaign ended, Luckin released the same merchandise again with a lower threshold or even for free, leaving consumers who had bought at a high price earlier feeling dissatisfied. At the same time, employees reported on social platforms that the merchandise was selling poorly, with inventory piling up at some stores, and materials such as stickers even being discarded or given away. From the teaser phase to the rerun, this collaboration reflects the gap between a brand's marketing节奏 and consumers' expectations. [more…]

Starbucks China officially announced on January 16 a collaboration with the Chinese animated classic Havoc in Heaven, launching a transforming cold brew latte and reusable straw merchandise inspired by the Golden Cudgel, set to go on sale on January 19. Once the news broke, loyal fans and IP enthusiasts were highly excited, but after launch, many netizens found that only the straws were available, while the most anticipated Monkey King head-shaped merchandise was nowhere to be found. Stores in Beijing, Liaoning, Guangdong, Shanghai and other places had very little material, prompting some to joke, "No head, what use is this iron stick?" Although the official had stated in advance that except for the launch cities, stock would arrive between the 21st and 25th, the pace of releasing drinks first and merchandise later, teasing appetites, still left many consumers disappointed. This article reviews the entire collaboration event and netizen feedback, and also reminds brands to prepare more thoroughly when planning such activities. [more…]

"Ne Zha 2" has surpassed 1.49 billion yuan at the box office, becoming the biggest winner of the Spring Festival season, with Cotti Coffee, Chagee, and Good Me securing co-branding rights from among numerous competitors. Cotti was the first to announce its collaboration details, launching 12 combo packages, each containing one voucher for any drink on the menu and one limited-edition merchandise item, with no cap on merchandise quantities, no need to rush-buy, and drink vouchers valid nationwide within three months. This unconventional move was praised by netizens as "treating consumers like human beings," standing in sharp contrast to the previous co-branding model of limited quantities, bundled sales, and two-cup minimums, and putting pressure on Chagee and Good Me, which have yet to announce their own terms. [more…]

After the TV drama To the Wonder became a hit, the grassland scenery and herder life of Altay, Xinjiang, moved countless viewers, and this "Altay fever" has swept into the new-style tea beverage sector. Under the name of its "Free Matcha" series, Auntea Jenny launched a tie-in with To the Wonder, including long-scroll painting cup sleeves, takeout paper bags, collaborative lenticular card sets, and student film cards, attracting a large number of consumers to snap them up. However, problems emerged on the very first day of the campaign: some stores stocked only 10 pieces of merchandise, takeout orders included the wrong cards, and when customers arrived at stores to pick up their orders, staff took back the student cards in person... Consumers complained endlessly, and customer service apologized everywhere. As observers of the coffee and tea beverage industry, Front Street Coffee also noticed the supply chain and store execution problems behind this collaboration. This article will provide a complete review of the incident and present feedback from all sides. [more…]

ChaPanda recently officially announced singer Huang Zihongfan as its LOHAS brand ambassador, launching a variety of freshly made fruit drinks and limited-edition merchandise bundles, which attracted a large number of fans to snap them up. However, after the campaign went live, problems kept cropping up: system crashes, orders being forcibly canceled, and insufficient stock of merchandise, one after another, sparking consumer dissatisfaction. Some netizens questioned whether the limited-edition merchandise had been intercepted internally by employees, but more witnesses and ChaPanda staff came forward to explain, saying that stores were equally caught off guard and that employees were under enormous pressure amid the chaos. The company apologized that same evening and promised to speed up restocking and put the items back on sale. [more…]

In the depths of winter, Mixue Bingcheng has once again become a hot topic thanks to its "Northeast Big Floral" elements. The brand launched a series of fridge magnets featuring floral padded jackets and crispy fries merchandise, drawing consumers in with rich Northeastern flair. However, unlike last year's nationwide campaign, this year only certain regions can participate, sparking discontent among southern consumers. At the same time, out-of-stock merchandise has also hurt the experience for some customers. This article sorts through the details of Mixue Bingcheng's marketing campaign, the cultural background of the Northeast Big Floral, and the current state and hidden concerns of merchandise promotions in the new tea beverage industry. [more…]

M stand recently launched a wooden fish (muyu) merchandise item, which sparked a buying frenzy among fans as soon as it went on sale. However, after receiving the product, many people found that this wooden fish couldn't produce a crisp, ethereal sound when struck, and it also had issues like scratches, rough craftsmanship, and a surface prone to showing hammer marks. It was criticized as a "beautiful piece of junk." At the same time, netizens' complaints about M stand's coffee quality control have resurfaced, with many arguing that its prices are higher than Manner and Luckin, yet its taste is not superior. M stand, which once won over fans with its petit-bourgeois vibe and consistent quality control, is now increasingly perceived by consumers as "the coffee isn't great, but the merchandise is decent." This latest quality failure with the wooden fish has left loyal fans even more disappointed. [more…]

The Christmas collaboration between Heytea and Hello Kitty was supposed to be a fan frenzy, but it was overshadowed by the chaos of scrambling for limited-edition tea bowls. The silver Hello Kitty-shaped tea bowl with a rose-pink tray is small, exquisite, and extremely scarce—each store only received 4 to 6 units, making it as hard to snag as concert tickets. However, before the event even began, consumers on social media reported that some store employees had reserved merchandise in advance for regular customers, and even second-hand platforms saw scalped pre-orders claiming "100% guaranteed stock" and "we'll get it for you." This is not the first time Heytea has encountered issues with collaboration merchandise leaking early and being resold internally; a similar controversy occurred earlier this year during its collaboration with Light and Night. Fans are calling on the brand to thoroughly investigate internal violations, regulate store behavior, and ensure the collaboration event is conducted fairly. [more…]